Here's what I did. I managed to get new pins from the Honda guy just south of Buffalo.(can't remember his name, but sells on eBay quite frequently.) But I took my old ones off by drilling as little as possible to get them out. They could be put back in again. Anyway, the fit is so tight, with the new pins, I didn't even punch them because I was so afraid of screwing up my new paint job. Anyway, I've ridden for a summer, nothing has moved. So, if you can get the old ones out without too much trouble, I'd just put them back in. Maybe a little crazy glue if you're worried.