SW Michigan (Battle Creek / Kalamazoo) born and raised, here. ..
You are sooooo dead on about Grand Rapids. . ..I went to college there thinking how kewl it would be in some 'progressive big city' like that. .. . . NOT. .. . oh man, I don't care what yer spiritual persuasion is, it was just too much. . .just in your face all the time, the total bible belt of the North. . .I mean, the neighboring county was DRY??? and everything shut down on Sunday. . .. it was just too weird, like pockets of the deep south are.. . no thanks
plus, GVSU really felt like a private bible college or something. . . totally not a public university vibe, courtesy of Van Andel et al. pulling the purse strings.
I'll take Ann Arbor or Kalamazoo any day, as far as college towns go. . .. .