My brushed chrome look was pretty bad and rusty. Looks ok in the pic in this thread, but looked bad in person. Without the chrome, the stainless/brushed look starts getting a golden hue. The black is nice and uniform. This specific version of Rustoleum came out looking like powder coat to me, at least for now anyway. And I like black pipes, but I wouldn't have gone this route if I had stock 4-4.