The main carb jets are worn and it blows a little/quite a bit of black smoke under hard acceleration and hogs gas.
I find this very unlikely. Fuel is not that abrasive. However, if you meant your main needles and needle jet, that is a distinct possibility, as they can vibrate against one another.
I have a new air filter element on the way so hopefully it won't run so rich when I get it fitted, but, the question is:
If I get my mechanic to take the carbs off the bike and recondition them, will I be opening up a can of worms?
His advice is that because the bike is so old, when he gets the carbs off, it could get expensive and ugly.
Some mechanics set you up for a bigger bill after the job has been started. This sounds like he is positioning the crowbar over your wallet before he even starts.
Duane balanced the carbs by ear for me. He said that he used to put the tubes and spagmometer (sp) on to get carbs all synched but after 30 years he found that by doing it by ear and feel he was always within 5 percent of perfect so he just uses his experience and nothing else now, and I am happy with that. TC
Its called a manometer or four of them for our bikes. (A Sphygmomanometer measures blood pressure). If Duane called it a spagmometer, I would question is knowledge. Further, I would only believe tuning four carbs by ear if I witnessed someone do it to TEN DIFFERENT bikes and each checked properly with guages afterward. Then I would recognize the skill. But, Honda techs were NEVER trained in this way, I believe.
After 30 years of repeated work, I too might look for ways to eliminate set up proceedures. And, if a bit of bravado would convince a customer to accept this practice and still pay me, well...
I hesitate to tell you that carb overhaul is not hard. I've found several people had a hard time doing things that I do routinely and easily.
Riding a bicycle is not hard. Learning to ride a bicycle is harder for some than others. Some people learn to do things well independently. Others, require an instructor to get it right. Some are much better at some other skill.
No, not everyone can rebuild carbs. But, how will you know until you try? If you are worried about messing up your only set. Practice on a similar set first. If you cannot gain confidence doing that. Then take your chances on paying someone else to do it for you.
Having said all that, have you simply tried to lower your needles one notch to lean the midrange?
Or, before that, have you read your spark plug deposits to verify you ARE running rich?
Post a detail pic of a spark plug. We can help.
Cheers,