I recently went from studs to spigots on my bike and the studs were very difficult coming out. I had to use a propane torch and even then, two of the holes stripped, requiring heli-coil.
My suggestion would be apply heat and then try your hand impact again. If you don't have a propane torch, get one. They are inexpensive enough and very handy. Breaking impact bits is never unusual. These little things take a beating and need to be exchanged frequently, even the more expensive Snap-On ones.