OK, we got the damn things off! Here's how it all went down...
First, more tools. Liquid wrench, acetone, a scraper and some spare razor blades. Yes, I know by now that's not the right scraper- the guys at the automotive store were FC about this stuff, so I grabbed that because hey, it's cheap and I need one anyhow.
We got some acetone smeared on the cylinder head and the worst of the gasket lifted off (80% came off in a couple of big chunks), and then sprayed some liquid wrench and acetone all around the base gasket. Back to the head for a few minutes of scraping, and then there was a "clunk!" and my brother was jumping up and down shaking his hand. Turns out he'd braced a piece of hardwood under the cam chain tensioner adjuster screw nubbin thing at the back of the cylinders, stuffed the end of a large crescent wrench under it as a lever and popped it off easy peasy. And barked his knuckles in the process.
There it is! The top is pretty well smooth, although it's got this orange varnish on it. Not sure how to get it off. Think I'll hit it with brake cleaner. By the time I'm done here I'll be broke and have a whole new collection of toxic and flammable chemicals!
The base gasket split in half, but seems to be coming off OK. Sleeves are clean.
There's the head and the cylinders, upside down. The underside of the head has some varnish, and a few spots where the gasket is cemented on super hard. We put some (very small) gouges in the surface, but nothing that goes all the way through from the outside to the inside that could provide a channel. It seriously feels like the baked-on gasket is harder than the aluminum. I'll hit that with break cleaner and a putty knife later this week. How clean do these things have to be? Is a bit of varnish OK as long as it's silky smooth, or do I want bare metal? Can I glue some fine sandpaper to a mirror and lap the whole surface flat?
Lots of varnish. >_<
Horrible picture (it was dark by now, and the garage is badly lit), but you can see that the base cylinder has much less of the orangey/yellowy/brownish varnish stuff, and a lot more just plain old charred paper. This is actually coming off OK, although it's not as smooth where it does lift off.
And there's the chain guide. It's baaaaaad. Glad we went down this far. There are some channels worn into the side of the the cam chain slot down the middle of the cylinder block as well. We'll check out the sides of the chain for wear, and see if it's stretched at all.
We'll also drop the oil pan and clear the oil strainer. I imagine all that rubber and most of the aluminum shavings are down there, which is why we didn't see more in the oil.
So, two questions:
If we run the oil out of it, can we put the (week-old, 6 mile) oil back in? I can't think of a reason not to save myself the thirty five bucks or whatever.
Any good recommendations for plugging up the gaping maw of a whole in the top of the engine block as we scrap all the old gunk off the top of it? Trying to minimize the crud going into the engine, as well as any chemicals (brake cleaner) we'll be using to loosen it.
Thanks for all the help, folks, this is an exciting project. I'm learning a ton, and look forward to riding the thing when it's done.