Don't forget you are changing the aspect ratio, too.
Recently I had the chance to run the same tire model on my 550F with two different sizes:
a) 90/90-19 front, 100/90-18
b)3.25-19 front, 4.00-18 rear
Both are Bridgestone BT45 and without taking measures they look like having the same dimensions.
The metric front tire felt it little bit "spongy" when leaning over. The 3.25-19 feels much firmer and makes me more confident when leaning a lot. Also on highspeed runs on the Autobahn, with the 3-25-19 the bike felt more stable.
I also ran the combination 3.25-19 front, 100/90-18 rear
Could not feel any difference between both back tires.
Both tire sets were inflated to the same pressure (36 PSI front, 40 SPI rear)
-> I'd try to get a 3.25-19, there are still enough tire models to choose from.