Yes the Eastwood kit seems to give you a dull silver finish that needs to be polished and will probably dull again like galvanized steel over time. I called Caswell and bought their smallest copy cad/zinc kit without the gloves, heater and zinc chunk for around the same price as the Eastwood kit so I'm anxious to get started. The main additional component with Caswell is the chromate additive that comes in a variety of colors including blue and yellow but only lasts one or two platings according to them so could get expensive. Also the Caswell operation requires a power supply rather than a couple of batteries and needs to be heated to 110 degrees unlike the Eastwood kit. Nevertheless I excited to start since I always have a bolt or two or cable end I'd like to clean up. I buy a lot of anodizing supplies from Caswell and I know they sell top notch stuff, albeit expensive. If this thread is still active, I'll post my results here and compare with the internet zinc plating I had done.