And thus another "best design possible" by the Hondagineers is revealed.
I don't understand what you are whining about. You don't know why it failed or what someone did to it to make it fail, but still make a snap judgment? I have a couple of those covers that still work fine, after nearly 40 years of use. However, if you over stuff the tool compartment bay with "extra things", it puts way more stress on that built in hinge. Anything that man can make, man can destroy via abuse or intention, no matter how it was designed. Engineers often try to make things "foolproof". But, there is always a new batch of fools trying a different way to screw things up. Many engineers just can't think like fool.
Anything on the bike will break with just the right type of abuse. And expecting man made sh!t to last forever (particularly sh!t made for the least amount of purchaser outlay), is a pretty strange concept, imo. Buy a new bike and see how long it lasts, abuse or no.