I'm going to give lots of details (so, sorry for the novel below) because I can't figure out why all of my lights aren't going down, just the running light circuit.
My headlight and all running lights are going dim/completely dark below 1200-1500 rpm. My dash lights are completely unaffected. My turn flashers and brake light are completely unaffected, but my taillight, headlight (high and low) running lights (front turn signals wired up only), and gauge lights are all doing the same thing.
So what has changed?
What has changed was that I put on new rear turn signals
I ran them as just turn signals (not running lights, I left that lead disconnected) and everything was fine. I decided I wanted them to be running lights and hooked the black wires into the taillight connector under the seat. At this point I noticed the headlight was dimming (to a set level every time) whenever the rear brake light came on. Similar to how you see headlights flash dim when people put their turn signals on sometimes. It was still fine at idle and everything. I figure I had feedback through a ground somewhere.
Before this, the headlight had never done this. I was using the same brand turn signals previously, I just got new ones.
I've since disconnected this wire so the rears are turn signals only.
Fast forward to two nights ago. It was cold, my seat had frost on it in the morning (parked outside).
When I started it up that morning I noticed that whenever I had the idle below ~1500 the lights dim and at idle they cut out completely. They flicker a bit at idle, indicative of current varying a little (cold idle so it wasn't perfectly smooth).
Did my battery freeze overnight? What's going on here? I know that the charging systems on these don't really "break even" until like >2000 rpm, but something's wrong here. All the cells are up to the correct marks in the battery.
Any suggestions?