If it were me I'd keep the aft sprocket and buy a good o-ring chain and make sure it is installed correctly.
Why not a good chain?
O-ring or X-ring chain AND both sprockets of good quality.
STOP saying stuff like this!
Fritz showed you the why.. but there is a principle here. If you dont actually know about the bike in question, bad advice is worse than no advice, and could lead to some poor, unsuspecting newb actually damaging his bike because of you.
Did you read the thread, and notice the number of people advising against O-ring chains on 550s?
/rant
What Fritz said. Non O-ring Chain on a 550. I also have had good success with DID. It was $40? But I understand the temptation of amazon prime
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/25583/25583e14e9a40bb20e623a5d24697398151e8973" alt="Smiley :)"
Whatever chain you get.. just compare it's width to your previous chain to make sure it is comparable.