The seller is insisting that I just fill out the previous owner's information on the bill of sale and be done with it.
That's what I would do just for the sake of ease and to get it over with.
But here's the problem with that approach. How many illegal activities to you see here:
1) Me filling in my information on the previous title in the blank "buyer" fields.
Probably not illegal, but probably in the grey area. If a bill of sale wasn't required, I would do it. However:
2) Me then filling out a bill of sale in the absence of the seller and the previous owner. Since the name on the BOS must match the name on the title, the seller told me to fill in the previous owner's name on the bill of sale, and forge his signature.
This I see as the big no-no. How do I know the bike is truly legit? How do I know the previous owner really sold the bike? I would be held responsible for something here.
In Michigan (where the bike was titled), you don't need a BOS. However, in order to legally "release" the bike, the buyer must fill out his information and sign on the title for it to be a done deal. Technically speaking, the bike is still in the previous owner's name, and not the seller.
Anyhow, I called the seller, and he gave me the run around at first. Then he finally agreed to sign/print the Bill of sale and the Power of Attorney documents that I've emailed to him and then notarize, and then mail them back to me. With those documents, I should be able to finally get this thing registered in my name. It's the safe, legal, and sure way to do it without me being thrown in jail if this thing really is a hot bike. The DMV lady (who was actually very helpful over the phone) was a little dumbfounded that the seller wouldn't have titled it once he purchased the bike, even dealers must do this.
From my research on the seller, he's legit. He buys and resales lots of bikes. Even then, I would recommend that he needs to get the title transferred over into his name so future buyers don't have to go through hassle.
Anyways, I should be receiving the proper documents later this week, so my mind is at ease.