the problem with BMV indiana is you can ask different people the same question and get different answers. i wouldn't take an answer over the phone either. i live in indianapolis and sometimes i go a BMV in a small town. they are more likely to let something like that slide.
That didn't help, I guess Monticello would qualify as a small town but the BMV was closed today so I went to the one in Delphi only to find the same ladies that work at the Monticello BMV.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d2eb0/d2eb00635ed50cb893ebe3317bd4a2ec1fd1d64f" alt="Shocked :o"
I rolled the dice and put last Saturdays date on it, filled it out where my name should be except where the previous owner screwed up and crossed my fingers.
Good news is I had the local police come over and do a VIN check and they told the bike isn't stolen after they looked it up.
Bad news is:
#1- It's an Ohio title and the sellers signature needs to be notarized. My insurance agent is a notary but he wouldn't touch it because he said an Ohio notary would have to notarize it.
#2- Where the seller goofed it's printed so you can still clearly see his name through the scribble and it should be obvious it was just a mistake, nothing more nothing less but nope, the BMV says he has to fill out an error correction affidavit stating simply that he screwed up where he printed his name.
So now I have the fun task of trying to track this guy down and get him to take care of getting the title notarized and fill out the affidavit. I'm really not looking forward to this but I do have 2 addresses to play with so wish me luck.