Yeah its a tough deal..we have seen the Return of The Fender ...a few times..
Had. Victory fan assure me they can do no wrong and all will be great..
Keep in mind though that even with the best resources, success is not guaranteed. Ie the Honda Fury that came out, too late to the dance. And all the"BETTER" than a pushrod v twins, that have been churned out, the last decade or more that are not setting the bike world on fire..
Using the Indian name borrows heavily on nostalgia, but the modern product is a world apart from the original..
For me, I want an original Indian, at least 10 times more than I want the afterborn version, just does not seem very interesting to me.
Also I dont like the look of the Victory motor, reminds me of an Asian product.. But I do like H-D.