If the 750 felt a bit wide to you, then you should look for a 550. Still plenty of power (I'm 6-4 225 and had no issues keeping up with highway traffic here in Chicago), but smaller all around.
If you happen to find a cafe'd bike you like, just be wary of pods and make sure you can do a thorough test ride.
Lots of members use them and are very happy. But if you spend some time here you will see at least one post a week from someone who can't get the fueling right on their bike and 99% either replaced the stock airbox with pods, or bought somebody elses conversion that came with pods installed.