Tell that to the people that lost their houses in the last crash that real estate is a great investment.
Real estate prices are much different here and now is a great time to buy nearly everywhere.
Shame on you if you bought a house you could not afford or with a crazy ARM mortgage.
Unfortunately it wasn't just the people who made bad financial decisions that got taken down along with the collapse. We did everything right when we bought our house in Denver. Bought well within our means, and had a low fixed-rate mortgage. It was a small house, but had everything we needed, and it wasn't painful to make the payment every month. In fact we were paying more than the minimum to knock the principal down faster. We got it at the beginning of 2006, and when the bottom fell out two years later the value of our house dropped 35% almost overnight, which more than obliterated any equity we had built up.
It was just the luck of the draw. We couldn't have known beforehand that it was probably the worst possible time to buy a house in the past century. Up until then real estate was almost a guaranteed good investment. We didn't forcibly lose the house, though. We could have stayed there and kept paying on it no problem, regardless of the fact that it was worth far less than the current mortgage, but life had continued on, as it does. We had two children since buying the house and wanted to move to Texas to be with family. That was supposed to be our starter house, where we built up some equity and moved up to a nicer house once we had a family.
We took the hit, did a short-sale, and walked away from all the money and improvements we had put into that house over the course of 4 1/2 years. Now it's 10 years after we bought our first house, we have a 4 year old and 6 year old, and we're just now back to a financial situation where we can start looking to buy a starter house again. I regret buying that house when we did, but I don't beat myself up about it because we couldn't have known.
The experience hasn't turned me against buying, but it has made me even more cautious than I already was before, and it's significantly lowered my expectations of home ownership. I no longer look at buying a house as a financial investment. Financially, I'd be happy just to break even. My main issue is that I HATE renting. I don't like living in somebody else's house. I want to be able to do what I want to do to the place.
Sorry for rambling! I know you were talking about the people who went well above their means to buy houses they couldn't really afford, but there were a lot of us that did everything right, just at the wrong time, who got taken down along with them. At least in that relatively brief window of time, real estate was not a good investment.