Thanks for the advice guys.
Unfortunately all I have is the 6" wheel from MotionPro (purchased it with the adjustable sprocket), and all the bigger wheels on the island are crazy expensive, like $80+. No way I'm spending that much for a one-time use tool.
The wheel is locked in there good with several washers acting as spacers, and I torqued it down pretty good with my impact hammer. It's not going anywhere. My pointer is pretty solid, and I flipped the degree wheel outwards so I can see it better. And it only has it going in one direction anyway.
I have a long breaker bar I can use to turn the engine. Thankfully there's no load on anything, so I'm turning JUST the crank and cam, and can get precise movement without much effort.