You missed you're perfect opportunity! Your bike died and you let the pretty girl walk? Young and foolish...
You should have said, "Great, Youre so pretty you stop traffic, and then you go and kill my bike! How will I ever get home?" Dude, you gotta learn- then, when she pulls over, and walks up, hit her with, "Damn, did it hurt when you fell from Heaven?" Seriously disappointed in you...
As for the bike, the credit card gauge works perfectly well, if you measured with an accurate device. Double check your gauge measurement. Just because they were set, doesn't mean they can't be stuck now. You did have to let the bike sit for a bit, right? Possible some debris got in there or, that your measures are off. And this may not be your problem at all... But it's worth the check.