My XL250 has an exhaust leak where the muffler meets the header. Evidently there's supposed to be a gasket there:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c4c68/c4c682b57d4e668036b29cc6d0d0898263d907e9" alt=""
These are NLA and the one that has shown up on ebay in the past month is $30, and we can't afford that for our $500 Challenge bike. Here's a pic of it though:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/de7c9/de7c9cc17506758a90634c08be952a192268819d" alt=""
Any ideas of what we can use here? My Goldwing has a crossover between the pipes that uses a similar gasket but it's the wrong size. What do you think it's made out of? Our current plan is to shim it with a couple of layers of beer can aluminum; not sure if that'll do it though.