May I ask, why in the world would you immerse something in salt water for a day to test corrosion resistance? Very few things would withstand that unless fully treated inside and out with an impregnated layer, and bluing is not among them.
Cold bluing or hot bluing depend on an absolutely clean surface to start with. Then, the finish is extremely susceptible to corrosion from the slightest and briefest of contact. It must be cleaned or wiped down promptly else it will rust. Guaranteed.
Anyone with firearms experience will tell you that rifle or shotgun barrels wipe their barrels down after handling for this very reason.
I am unfamiliar with the Gibbs stuff, but if it is "wiped or sprayed" on, it will not adhere permanently and thus it will fail. When it does, rust will appear, perhaps in an unnoticed place too.
If a unique finish is something you seek, try a bit of experiementing with this: polish that piece that you blued back to raw with as high a polished finish as yo can endure. Then, using Acetylene, heat it from within to discolor it. When cooled, handle only with clean clothes, and powder coat clear or paint clear over it. It might just retain enough of the heat discoloration to give you what you need. It would work better with CroMo pipe or stainless, but you might just get there without distorting the tubing strength.