Adventures in carb cleaning
Gunk versus Yamaha carb cleaner
Well, I've read the threads here (and the FAQ) on how and what, so I decided to try cleaning some carbs myself. My 72 CB500 came with several sets of carbs, and through bar-buddies and my friends' old projects, I ended up with two more CB550 parts bikes, with more sets of carbs. Plus I bought a set from a SOHC4 member. All sets were pretty dirty; actual chunks of corroded aluminum falling off the main jet holder in some.
For the first set of carbs, I used the Gunk Carb Cleaner [part # CC3K] from an in-town Advance Auto. About $10USD for a gallon pail about 3/4 full of solution; includes an insertable half-qt perforated parts tin with handle. I had to separate the carbs from the backing plate as I could not find a watertight bread baking pan to put the whole rack in, so I just dunked them in the pail, with welding rod "S"-hooks attached so I could pull the parts out.
I let the individual carbs, bowls and cover removed, soak for about 16 hours. Worked pretty well. Gunk leaves a greasy-feeling surface behind when it is done. But nice and clean. Requires a bit of scrubbing with a fine brass wire brush and a 2" paint brush with half the bristles cut off to get rid of extreme dirt/corrosion which the Gunk had loosened up.
I had to go fairly far afield to find some Yamaha carb cleaner. A Kawasaki/KTM dealer in another town had it (he also sells Yamaha jetskis; but not cycles...go figure). I got two one-quart bottles; ~$10USD a bottle. Plastic bottles.
For the next set of carbs, I bought an empty gallon pail from Ace Hardware, along with some 22 gauge wire (for hanging parts - this stuff does a job on exposed skin). I also poked some holes in a tunafish can to keep submerged parts separated. Next I mixed the Yamaha stuff 1:1 with water (as advised in another thread here), and put it in the gallon pail. (The pail came with a nice sealable metal lid; unlike 3# coffee tins - they have plastic lids). Not having a hotplate (or wife), I chose the kitchen stove to heat my cleaner. I took a frying pan and put about 1 1/2" of water in it, and brought it to a boil, and set the pail of cleaner in the water. Checking constantly with a Centigrade thermometer, I kept the water boiling, replenishing as necessary (about every 30 minutes) to keep water level constant. I let it boil for about three hours. [Warning: if you do this indoors, it will stink, and you *will* have a sore throat]. I kept exhaust fans on and windows open. The temp of the Yamaha solution never rose above 82*C, and only took 30 minutes to reach that temp. The Yamaha solution does boil off however, so I kept replenishing the water level in the Yamaha solution as well as the frying pan. (I'm not sure if it was the water or the Yamaha stuff that was boiling off).
The carbs came out nice and clean, but after drying, they all had a white "ash" on their surfaces. It will wipe/scrub off, but is rather puzzling.
All carb parts, whether Gunk or Yamaha treated, were washed off in soapy water, rinsed, then blown dry. I wear rubber gloves when handling caustic substances.
The final treatment was to boil another set of carbs (lots of these old dirty junk Honda carbs <sigh>) in the straight Gunk solution for three hours, in the water/frying pan. Actually, I let the first one soak overnight in Gunk unheated, then heated it in the morning for three hours. Same process of replacing boiled-off water in the pan every 30 minutes, keeping it at a boil. Solution constant at 82*C. I left the pail lid lying on top of the pail, not sealed, just sitting on top of the wire hangers. Keeps most of the condensation in.
My conclusion is that for the best cleaning, boil the carbs. Both Gunk and Yamaha seem to be equally good at it, with the above mentioned greasy/ashy surface differences. Additionally, the Gunk is not as noxious or irritating as the Yamaha. And it costs about half as much for approximately equal amount of solution. Both can be reused, but be sure to seal the pails for storage. The Yamaha stuff evaporates rather quickly. It also rusts the pails it is used in.
The Gunk is advertised as being environmentally friendly as well.
I'm going to keep my eyes open for a hotplate at garage sales, as well as a larger pan/pot for the boiling water. I'm not sure why the solution never gets above 82*C when the water is boiling...maybe the heat radiates away from the exposed areas of the pail??? And I certainly won't be boiling Yamaha cleaner in the house anymore...coff, coff...A table off the back porch is the approved location now.
That concludes this exercise.
Some off-topic notes:
- Gunk Carb Cleaner - part # CC3K - at Advance Auto -
http://www.partsamerica.com/ProductList.aspx?mfrpartnumber=CC3K- Yamaha Carb Cleaner part # ACC-CARBC-LE-QT -
(available from pretty much any Yamaha dealer)
- For ~$2.50, you can get a 6"/150mm pocket scale/square with a sliding "T" clip at Sears or any good hardware store for setting the float height. The CB500 calls for 22mm. Works good. I followed the instructions for the 750 carb Rebuild at SALO.
- Step-by-step carb cleaning/rebuilding (for 750 carbs) -
http://www.salocal.com/sohc/tech/carb/carb.htm- NAPA has the o-rings for the "T" fitting between carbs (as noted in another thread here), part # 727-2605, available in box of 10.
- I used the Keysler carb kits; these are junk. I ended up using only the top gasket and the bowl o-ring. The bowl o-ring had to be stretched a bit, and held in the groove with Vaseline so it could be installed.
- Harbor Freight has a Metric o-ring assortment for ~$10USD that has just about every other o-ring you will need, including manifold o-rings. Part # 91512
- Sears has the 6mm and 8mm wrenchs you will need for the choke adjusters and sync-nuts. Or you can buy the "Open End Standard Ignition Wrench Set" part # 944778; inch-pattern, but "close enough".