What kind of shape was the bike in when you got it back?
If it was well maintained, i doubt he was the thief, could have bought it at a yardsale, flea market, pawnshop..
Around here thieves usually spraypaint them if they are riding them, and tend not to maintain them.
This is what I suspected happened to it (torn up and repainted.) It actually is in about the same shape as it was when stolen, not bad. The brakes are adjusted up and the gears adjusted.
Seat has a little wear (gel pad), but its normal wear n tear. He was pissed that he couldn't keep it, having the finders keepers attitude. We didn't have much chance to discuss it, because the cop was there early, and most of my time was spent going back home to look for my receipt. I find it unbelievable that I still had paperwork. I am certain I wouldn't have the bike back in my garage now without that receipt. I am also certain that if I wouldve not had the receipt, I'd have driven home, got the bolt cutter from downstairs, and driven back to that light pole and freed what was mine,
and left the police out of it.
I went the legal route earlier with the police report when it was stolen, so I went the legal route
again with the paperwork when it was found. From my point of view, the dude is a douche bag.
I got my bike back in pretty good shape, so like I said earlier, I'm over it. To push it any furthur
is a little dangerous because if the guy is the original thief, he knows where my house is. So
I don't want a pissing contest if he's the vindictive type. I've seen that kind of scenario before,
and often times in similar situations it's just not worth it.