Ok so did some more plug chops. I wanted to see the state before I go do another few dyno pulls.
I honestly don't know what to think. I'd like to know how many of you actually use plug color to determine mixture. What my plugs show doesn't make sense to me. I've read many people (on the forum and elsewhere) saying that you can't reliably read plug color any more with today's gas. Is this true? Does different gas (octane and Mobil vs Shell vs Cumberland Farms) make any difference?
This was my idle plug chop in the middle of July. Plugs were fairly even in color.

This is the first idle chop today with the same mixture screw settings and same pilot jets as before.

2 and 4 look very lean. 1 looks perfect. Then I decided to do another chop with fresh plugs after adjusting the mixture screws. I actually forgot that these screws are out for leaner and in for richer. As you can read in the picture I went OUT on #4 all the way to 1 full turn out and it shows a darker plug...? I'm confident my idle chop is done properly.

I was confused so I put the mixture screws back to 1/2 turn out, put new plugs in and went for a ride to do a pilot jet plug chop at just above 1/8th throttle. This is where I'm feeling some burbling, I was assuming it would be very rich. 1-4 left to right.

After seeing this, I turned the #2 mixture screw in 1/4 turn and it ran worse. Right now, all my settings are back to where they were at the start of the day (1/2 turn out). I didn't seem to make any progress, haha.
My bike idles nicely at 1500rpm, though with current mixture screw setting. Any thoughts on the above? Sorry for the rambling.