I don't really care if you both are engineers. MOST people here are not.
Defining their being? Hipster bull? You're making it sound way worse than it is, haha.
Your test with two bikes won't work. Why? Because it's not double blind. Don't even bother doing it.
Just have enough horsepower to putt around a parking lot? Akin to removing a carbs spark plug? Again, you're exaggerating. A perfectly tuned factory bike with a fat person riding it will loose in a drag race vs a podded hipster bike ridden by a skinny...well, me...145lb dude. What does that mean? To me it means that a podded bike that's decently tuned will still be pretty good and that weight matters more in this case.
To the PO, it's your bike, just know that an airbox IS better and pods are worse, but not really THAT much worse. It could be possible to get it running well.
---
1978 Honda CB550K
[/quote]
Yep, most are not. But some have asked. Just answering the question.
Yeah, lots of hipster bull. Its okay, some are into that.
Right. That's the issue with the test. Lack of a control. Should have each motor dyno'ed stock first. That would help a bit. But really at the end of the day few would care. Most are okay with pods being "good enough" anyway.
Absolutely. How can you be okay with a known power loss, but not okay with someone pointing it out? Lots of things go into making the motorcycle work as a system. You are correct that a fat guy is slower on the same bike then a horse jockey. So what then?
Try a double blind test with a fat guy and a skinny guy on pods. This could be fun! I will volunteer as the fat guy.
Honestly not trying to argue, unless about hipster, then I am firm at the "burn at the stake" stance.
I think the most important thing in any of this is knowledge. I am fine with a guy that KNOWS that he is making a HP sacrifice for a look. It is calculated. Motorcycles are tools. Each do a job. And if the job is to have a look and wow girls then fine. Build to that purpose. But I do take issue when people perform a mod, and then talk about the mythical gains because they do not know any better. I feel that knowledgeable people have a duty to at least explain that to a newbie. Again, not saying hold a gun to their head and yell "NO PODS EVER". Some times the advice is harsh though. It is what it is. This happens to be a very light forum. Come on over the Caferacer.net......we have a different tone....lol
This is my chopper. Don't care about the power loss of the stacks. I just need enough HP to putt my fat butt to the bar and back.

But the Seeley will run the stock airbox until I can make the needed changes to actually make more HP then stock.
Different bike for a different reason.
