Since #1 doesn't get "as hot", I believe you have spark, but no fuel going to that cylinder. The float is probably stuck, and the jets clogged preventing fuel from entering the combustion cycle. If you had no spark, your cylinder/pipe would be cold as ice.
Address the carb sticking float as suggested by rapping on the body of the carb with a rubber handle. If it does not stop leaking, shut off the petcock, and open the drain screw on the bottom of the carb bowl (large flat blade screw). Gas will run out of there, so have a small catch cup. Rap the carb body while its draining and examine the gas afterwards. Dirty, floating gunk in it? If so, clean the interior of your tank and rid it fully of rust. If you don't, you will have persistent problems with debris, stuck floats, and intermittent firing on the cylinders.