What do you think the 750 caliper & arm are going to do? It is a single piston caliper just like you have so you are not going to gain anything. First, ensure that you have the caliper arm aligned evenly on the rotor. Then check to see if the caliper body is square to the rotor face. You may need to put a new set of EBC pads on it and sand your rotor to remove the black build-up.