It's also possible that the petcock handle is installed wrong. If you've ever had one apart, you'll see a rubber disc with four holes. On the back side of the handle is a groove. That groove routes fuel to the ON and RES circuits. The rest of the handle backside is flat. If it's installed incorrectly, you're actually turning the fuel OFF.
If you have the early style petcock with sediment bowl, they're cheap and easy to rebuild.