I think he meant some people would say yes to your original question, and others would say no. Meaning we don't really know. Lol.
Exactly. Kind of like arguing over what the best electronic ignition is. Everyone has their favorite-
Theoretically, the earlier year carbs would run better given their lack of EPA intervention on exhaust emissions. Also, the earlier year carbs can be tuned more easily, and across a wider range. So in effect, one should be able to extract more horsepower from the engine. But this is all subjective and I have no evidence from side-by-side Dynos runs for multiple year bikes in equal condition with stock systems.
And all of this is superseded by the fact that
everyone knows Flake Sunrise Orange bikes are fastest. And Planet Blue Metallic the slowest-