The lifter plate must be drawn into complete contact with all four towers before proper torque can be acheived. You aren't just tightening the bolts against spring tension. Once you get close you will notice that the bolt is firming up as the lifter plate contacts the tower. When all four bolts feel like they are firming up, then you torque to the proper setting. "Dry" fit it without the springs to see how it should go together. As I and others have mentioned, if you don't tighten evenly or if you don't get the backer properly meshed up to start with, the lifter will be unable ot contact the towers properly and you will either crack it or snap a bolt.