so, to the OP: since you're being presented with these options.
just a FYI if you're unfamiliar with dealing with these gauges. It can be a rabbit hole. The biggest issue is removing/re/installing the stainless steel crimp ring that holds the gauges together. If you've never done it, it can be.....frustrating. I've done it once, and needed my home made jig to make it ok. Then, if you replace the faceplate on one, you will,probably wanna do the other one.
And the aftermarket faceplates are made of white plastic, with the green coating, and honda's are green plastic. This creates a "whiteout" effect at night with the aftermarket. Some solve the issue by changing bulbs. I used a 3m, stick on, translucent green film on the back of the faceplate. Maybe it's been "fixed", dunno.
And it depends on what matters to you.