Chuck,
Is the plug wet after a plug chop with the no fuel burn indicated on the Colortune? Check both plugs to see if they are wet, if they are, it could be the one ignitor for 1-4 cylinders. But hey, for $10 each, you might have to go through a couple. New ones are much preferred, but as you know not cheap. Swap the ignitors around and see if you get 2-3 dead. If so, buy another $10 GL1100 ignitor, or send that one back. The fellow said unconditional returns, I believe...
Charlie