It shouldn’t make a difference.
I just rebuilt my petcock/fuel tap with a kit from 4 into 1.
I did not replace the 4 holed seal (my issue was that reserve position wasn’t working.
I could have replaced it but when I compared the seal to the oem, the oem part looked slightly larger.
I am wondering if you go and get an oem one if your problem will be fixed.
If you take it apart again, please take close up photos of the 4-hole gasket fitted in the petcock, and the inside flat face of the fuel knob that sits against that gasket.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk