It looks like this if you’ve never had the engine open guys.
Cheers
When the chain isn't adjusted it can get slack enough to ride high on the sprocket and cut grooves into the pivot area of the 'horseshoe'
The grooves are beaten as much as worn in and a burr forms preventing movement.
Beating the tensioner down is a quick 'fix' but if it gets too tight there is no way of loosening it up ( although, sometimes, turning engine backwards with adjuster bolt loose works)
The only way to fix this is remove the rivet and file off the burrs or fit a new tensioner(after you have bottom end stripped)
Front fender looks like its off a CJ250/360, they are plastic and were painted from new ( although a 'darker' yellow)
PJ