Author Topic: Classic & Motorcycle Mechanics "recycled road tests"  (Read 907 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Trevor from Warragul

  • Expert
  • ****
  • Posts: 1,089
Classic & Motorcycle Mechanics "recycled road tests"
« on: April 11, 2007, 12:50:10 AM »
I sent an e-mail to the editor (Rod) querying the non-receipt of the April issue (which I have since received).  I thought I'd also give some feedback on the magazine & I included the following lines:

"Also, I don't want to read what are essentially reruns/reprints of road tests from the 1970's/1980's - I read them then and I don't want to read them now! I want to read about 70's, 80's bikes being used in the modern world!"

and (this probably got his goat):

"In other words, stop being a little lazy & lift your game!"

I got this reply:

"Recycled road test? Look, Mechanics is dedicated to the bikes of the 70s and 80s, and we are priveleged (sic) to have John Nutting writing for us each month. John was there at the time, and is probably the only biking journalist still in the business who can offer genuine evalations of what these bikes were like to ride at the time, with the benefit of the hindsight he can bring to bear on it from a modern perspective. We also have an archive of original shots which were taken at the time, most of which never appeared in print.

Everything in Mechanics is brand new writing and photography with the exception of Johns monthly MIRA Files slot, which is the only bike magazine feature appearing anywhere which can capture the nostalgia of the original shoots and roadtests by the man who actually did them at the time. That's six pages each month out of 116 - I'm sorry if thats really too much for you to bear.

Perhaps you might also like to give a thought to those of our readers who weren't around at the time, and who don't have an encyclopaedic knowledge of the contents of every bike magazine published during the 70s and 80s. They appear to be in the vast majority, for yours is the only voice complaining about "recycled road tests"."

Am I truly the only person who finds the "recycled" road tests an annoying waste of space?

Okay, I'm ready to be flamed...

Trevor

1971 Kawasaki H1A
1972 Honda CB350F
1976 Moto Morini 3 1/2 Sport
1978 Honda CBX
1997 Suzuki Bandit 1200
1999 Ducati Monster 750

Offline oldbiker

  • Expert
  • ****
  • Posts: 1,101
  • I HATE RAIN
Re: Classic & Motorcycle Mechanics "recycled road tests"
« Reply #1 on: April 11, 2007, 02:21:49 AM »
I only wrote to C&MM once and the reply I got was very rude and unhelpful. I have not bought the magazine since. Maybe when it gets a new editor I will start again.

Offline mcpuffett

  • Master
  • *****
  • Posts: 2,354
Re: Classic & Motorcycle Mechanics "recycled road tests"
« Reply #2 on: April 11, 2007, 04:17:07 AM »
Hi Trevor, i have just switched from reading classic bike & classic bike guide to classic motorcycle mechanics as i was getting fed up with reading the same old stuff over and over , hope this one does'nt turn out the same?   mick.
Honda CB750 KO 1970,   Honda VTX 1300 2006, Lancaster England.

eldar

  • Guest
Re: Classic & Motorcycle Mechanics "recycled road tests"
« Reply #3 on: April 11, 2007, 06:20:15 AM »
Well lok at it from this point. I dont get any of these rags. I dont get any of them at all. I was not really around, at least not old enough to remember ANY of these tests. So if I were to pick up one of these mags, I would love to read the old tests. It gives a look at the bike you will not find these days AND from an era where the latest and greatest was not covered in plastic or have HD on it.

That said, I would also like to see NEW tests done in todays world yet in some ways I would not. What could they write about in a new test in todays world? That the bikes lack accel? Braking sucks and handling is subpar? Would you want to read that? Cause if you compare this bike with anything today, it does not come close. Now maybe instead of your regular road test, maybe have articles about different builds such as engine mods or other chassis and even electrical mods.

Offline Raul CB750K1

  • Old Timer
  • ******
  • Posts: 3,881
Re: Classic & Motorcycle Mechanics "recycled road tests"
« Reply #4 on: April 11, 2007, 08:50:08 AM »
I have already commented here that CMM is the only foreign -from a spanish point of view- that I buy every month. Actually, import magazines are rather expensive so what I do is to buy them in set every four or five months, at half the cover price, from a guy in UK. I love that magazines, because it cover mostly japanese bikes, have tons of tech articles with good pictures, and the MIRA files articles are also quite interesting. They are such a good technical database that I scan the articles and keep them in the computer because I don't have more space to store magazines.

If you have a feeling of deja-vu with a bike magazines, what would you feel with a running magazine? or a pregnant woman magazine? Those magazines exhausted the subjects to deal with decades ago, but roll on over and over to please new readers. At least they can cover tests of new gear or new technologies, but in a classic bike magazine there is no such thing.

I work as a freelance bike journalist too. Obviously, when you have to write about something you didn't know first hand, you have to rely on books and magazines of the era, and you need to cross-check some of them to make sure the figures are right. Having a journalist that indeed lived during the time and had first-hand experience is an invaluable asset. Alan Cathcart works for the same magazine I have worked for. Never met him, but somebody like him, who has travelled the world to test bikes, who have met the big fish of the business, and has been doing so for the last years, can write about bikes much better and more than I could have in my lifetime where my first source of income is not bike-related.


Raul