#2 of course.... i know the keepers are 2 pieces.... the seats are obviously supposed to be one piece..... and therein lies the problem.... i haven't gotten the head off yet... maybe later tonight... if im lucky there will just be a little ding in the top of the piston.... and hopefully no other damage... luckily i wasn't going anywhere when it happened, just idling and got it shut off rather quickly. from what i have read here new valves are hard to come by and quite expensive. so i hope that isn't going to be required(wish me luck)