I say no shock is any better than any other shock. They are all the same in their own way. Think of it like this. Do you need a shock with heavy dampening if you only weight 120 pounds? No so that progressive may not be the shock for you. Say you are 250 or more, is that Ikon going to work, maybe not. Point is a person just has to look at their weight, bike weight, driving style and if they carry any other weight sometimes. Once the person has these factors, then they can start to look at shocks and see what might work the best.
The shock from jcwhitney have worked fine for some people, original work for others.
So ultimately, get shock brands form people and where you can get more information, but dont buy based on what someone you have never met, says.
Besides the best shocks would have progressive dampening as the shock compresses, constantly variable spring rates and the dampening affect would not change with heat of cold.
I dont think these are made at all or if they are, cost is probably $1000 or more.