I had 591's on the Hondamatic and have now switched to longer lasting 491's. Vintage looks are not important, but good handling is. I think the 591's were overkill now, since the old Honda was not as capable as the tires were. I have ran Metzlers in the past on a BMW and found them to rather fast wearing as well. I would guess that most name brand tires are pretty much the same, but I would stay away from the off brand, low dollar tires that are out there.