It sounds like you've already ruled out the battery, but for future reference, we check batteries at the shop like this
1. disconnect battery
2. hook up battery charger (not just a trickle charger, a regular charger with a boost/start setting)
3. hook up your battery tester on top of the charger leads
4. turn it to fast charge, give it a few seconds for everything to come up
5. turn the charger to boost/start for a few seconds only. If it pegs your meter, your plates are shorted, period. Replace the battery, put it on a low charge for a little while (45 mins to an hour so your alternator isn't having to work so hard to catch up), fire it up and check your output.
If your battery is even a little iffy, get rid of it, it'll only cause you troubles on down the road.