bryanj and bwaller, you were right...it's from the base gasket.
Finally have another chance to work on the bike, had crap every weekend for a month (wedding season, ya know).
Now that I've got everything back in order (as far as o-rings go) I'm trying to get the cylinder head cover back on. It won't seem to fit. If I take the cam shaft off, it fits like a glove, so it's got to be something with that. The tach screw is all stripped out, so I couldn't get the tach gauge disconnected from the cylinder head, and I'm guessing the teeth just don't line up, but you would think that they would "meet" if i crank the kick starter by hand a couple of times...it doesn't want to. I've gotten the head on a couple of times and the screws tightened, but when I (slowly) crank the kick starter, it seems to get hung up on something and locks up. Is there a trick to getting the cover on correctly, or just trial and error until it fits?