Your not using the same pad, or wheel for all three compounds are you? If you are you need to thouroughly rake the wheel to remove any microscopic metal particles from the wheel, as well as any compound that remains from the previous application...so if your using the same wheel for black as rouge, then you will always have black in it...does that make sense? It is also important to have the right wheels...sisal to start w/ black emory comp., spiral 2nd with brown tripoli, and loose cotton, or flannel w/ white rouge. It sounds like you got the clear off, and sanded pretty good, but might be taking a step backwards with the buff and polish steps. What kind of buffer and what size wheels(8",10", 12") are you using?