I used the Victor-Reinz head gasket that came in the Versah kit, along with the O-rings. I didn't worry about the smaller holes in the gasket and just put the damn thing together. The O-rings will conform to the opening anyway, so it should not be a big deal. The much higher quality head gasket is what should make the big difference. The OEM gasket was a POS IMHO. It should not have been acting like a wick.
So far I have about 300 miles on the bike since the re-gasketing, and no leaks.