First of all, Tom - sorry to hear about your other two toes...
Secondly, love the Oliver avatar! Brings back memories.
As long as your buddies are cool*, you can get them each something unique to them. Season 1 of Seinfeld / Season 812 of The Simpsons, etc. Music's also a great idea. Something they'll hang onto and enjoy, not just let collect dust.
*If you've had groomsmen forced on you (future brothers-in-law, etc.) it might be safer to get them all the same thing. That way you don't have to listen to years of complaining about how somebody else got a better gift, blah, blah, blah...
BTW, are we too late to talk you out of the whole thing in the first place?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7051c/7051cff17e1f1474398370b1e3ea43246f959159" alt="Undecided :-\"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1533f/1533f68a063596772097a69ebe28b722c35ffda6" alt="Grin ;D"