Sorry moto but I do not believe those guys. I use a fram in my bike and it works absolutely fine. I have used fram in my cars for years and never had an oil related problem EXCEPT when my oil lines blew out from being old. Hardly filter related.
I DO feel the cartridge filters are better on our bikes than the spin ons are.
Also, there wasa person who only got the gasket, you got screwed somehow. I ALWAYS get the EVERYTHING when I get my fram from walmart.
That knize page, how long ago did they test the fram? Fram is now made my honeywell, no longer allied signal.
I have not seen any better quality in any other filter I have looked at.
I guess use what you want but I refuse to believe some little family project where the person pretends to know what they are talking about.
Now if UL did tests or some University, I would be inclined to believe them. I do not trust consumer reports too much, seen them wrong too many times.
To each their own. . . but personally, I set a Fram, a Honda OEM, and the Wix side by side and could
see obvious quality differences. The Honda and the Wix had thicker rubber gaskets in the center, around the hole, that were clearly formed - where the Fram gasket was lumpy and off center. The Wix and Honda both seemed a bit heavier, too.
Also,
cardboard inside of the Fram oil filter?? That, NO other manufacturers use? (from dood's quality test) What's up with that? OH wait. . ..must be 'Aerospace grade cardboard' or something, right?
All I know, is since Home-Ec class I learned that there are PLENTY of "gotcha" quality items out there that are made to just make a quick buck, over quality (ESPECIALLY products directed towards women). From what I have heard from some old school peeps in the hot rod world, Fram (like Pabst) USED to be of good quality but now they are just riding on an old brand name cred (similar to many other makers out there) that has long since sold out quality to profits.
Oh, and Wix are made by Dana Corporation - well known for some of the highest quality vehicle axle and suspension components, among many other things. I see the 'Honeywell" name even on cheap made in China fans (I have one).
I will take someone's home brew testing - as long as they are approaching it rationally (and rather retentively) like that guy - ANY DAY over a bunch of ubiquitous marketing and brand name placements like Fram seems to have.