Jheart, I was having a whir noise too when I hit the starter button. No engine spin. I took the starter off and sure enough the sprocket connecting to the starter in the engine case spun both ways. Seeing as how I have the engine apart anyway I thought I'd replace the starter clutch. Took the clutch basket cover off, clutch basket off, and oil pump cover. After that I started playing with the starter clutch some more and spraying some WD-40 up into the roller, spring, spring cap area as best I could. Starter clutch started working almost immediately. The catch there's still a slight amount of play in it whereas my replacement starter is dead solid. Looked in the oil pan... springs, roller, spring cap. Might as well do it right so I tried to get the rest of the starter assembly out from the oil pan. Had to take off the right side crank pressure release case. I had no luck whatsoever. Maybe another 1/4 inch and it would work out. So I guess that answers my question... I have to split the cases.
Any luck with yours?