So, ultimately, I was using the Evapo-rust and the tank was coming out great. And I have come to several conclusions concerning the pros and cons of it and vinegar.
Vinegar PROS- It's pretty cheap. You could fill an entire 5 gallon tank for around $5 or $10 bucks. This makes it pretty easy to just fill it and let it sit.
Vinegar CONS- It seems to take a looooong time and isn't as effective on the heavily rusted areas. These required scraping eventually and later some wire brushing. The main reason I don't like to use vinegar (I was quickly reminded) is the smell. The process smells like rotten eggs. It stunk my whole apartment up.
Evapo-Rust PROS- 1. Just put it in and it works. It dissolves the rust and ONLY the rust. It wot harm the metal. It's non-toxic and non-corrosive. environmentally friendly. It's reusable. What little smell there is, is not offensive at all. Due to space constrictions, I do a lot of my bike repairs in my apartment, so odor counts. Ultimately, I think it does a better job in the end.
As for the tank I was working on... it developed a leak in the front corner. It had rusted through at the seam and only started to leak in the final stages of the process. Closer inspection of the outside showed that a chip or two had turned into a rusty spot right on the seam. When the inside met the outside in the middle, it was all over. It's a shame too because the outside actually looks pretty good.
Anyway... Can I weld that? JB Weld and seal it? Or should I chalk it up to experience and just get another tank?
Evapo-Rust CONS- The only con is that it's costly. Because of this I couldn't fill the tank to the top and had to keep rotating and shaking it.
Hi,
have you ever tried molasses?
Works wonders, smells like beer, gets in all nooks and crannies, does not arm paint or chrome and is ok for the environement ... But it shure is nasty on rust,
For 20$ worth of molasses and a kid's pool you could dip a hole bike and get it rid of years of rust...
I use 5 water to 1 molasses and it really works great.
The only down side is how long it takes.
From 2 to 4 weeks depends of how bad the parts are.
À+
Crom.
Cromoly.