Only thing I can't think of is that you set up the gap in the wrong place. As you can see, the points plate can rotate on the base, and then, the right points sit on a "sub-plate" that can rotate over the primary plate.
You must gap first the left points, when the cam is at the point that the opening is the biggest. Then, align the firing mark of the 1-4 cylinders, and then rotate the primary plate so the points start to open. Thus you are adjusting the points to OPEN when the firing mark is aligned.
Then you do the same for the other points and cylinders, but you don't rotate the primary plate but the secondary plate -so you don't modify the setting of the left points.
I'm talking by memory, so I don't remember whether the left points were for cyl 1-4 or 2-3. Somebody correct me if I'm wrong, but the gap in the points adjust the number of degrees the points are closed -and the coil is energized and so, stores energy-, while the rotation of the plate adjusts the moment of firing -points opening-