Cliff keep what you got, I doubt they were super shiny, ie polished to bright sheen, before chroming..
In fact it is very difficult to find somone to chrome to stock factory look.
The vendors were building stuff out of fresh clean metal, and then it was production chromed, ie, only polished to remove obvious flaws, degreased racked and plated..
Most rechromed parts on Japanese restos are overchromed.. some like the shinier look, but it will probably cost you points in a show.