I tend to like telecasters so I looked this one up because it sounded familiar to me. I remember trying one of those out at a local store a while back. For me, I loved the price obviously, since it was well under $200 out the door but the other thing was, the low action feel and the thinner neck. I have much smaller hands than you, I'm sure, so I could get some good play out of it right off the bat without having to make adjustments for "woman hands".
I love my Ovation electric acoustic and my Les Paul but I worry about messing them up. This one sounds good, feels good and wouldn't break my heart if something happened to it.
I think it's all in what you like to play, the individual feel for your hands and if you plan on just flipping it for something else or keeping it. I had a ball with it on just a simple little amp in the store. I'm no rock star by any means and haven't played either of my current guitars for a while now, but I would probably consider spending the loot on that one for a cheaper version of a tele when I finally get some more time to play again. (hopefully soon)
I think you decide if it's a good deal by what you are giving up. What is your amp worth to you or someone else? New in the store, the tele goes for around $170 I think. New in someone's house is $120. Still in the plastic is nice but what temps/humidity/children/pets.... did he keep it in? That drops the value for me, especially since he hasn't even bothered to play it since buying it. He may not appreciate it like you would. I look around people's digs to get an idea if they are telling me the whole truth about how something was treated.