I don't know about Insurance companies in the States, but here in the Uk I paid about £100 for what we call 'fully comprehensive' insurance. The agreed value of my CB400f was £1,000. Three months later, my bike was stolen from my back yard from behind a locked gate and the moronic idiots who took it ran it about half a mile and set it on fire to destroy fingerprint evidence. The company paid up (less £50 excess liability) and I was able to buy another CB400f off eBay. Without that insurance I, as a pensioner, could not have afforded to have another bike. Now make your decision!