I bought one from Honda.
It needs to be open cell foam (you can breathe through it) that can withstand fuel and oil vapor without deterioration. Needs to be about 1/4 inch thick.
Someone suggested cutting one from a thin Scotchbrite pad. If you do this, make sure it fits tight. Scotchbrite is abrasive. So, I expect it vibrating about inside would wear at metal coatings.
Cheers,